Given that this game is very much set in a specific time period, I feel that it does not actually give a very good impression of that period in a military sense. The rock/paper/scissors combat system is actually (despite overlays of complexity) a bit crude, especially as it now seems to kill whole units, rather than weakening all involved. This approach may be valid for Napolionic period warfare, where infantry/cav/art all had a significant role and had to be balanced off against each other, but is far less valid in the earlier period.
C16th and C17th warfare rarely used "light infantry" as such, wherere as in practice this is 90% of what is used in game: what was used was shot, which were effective mainly as companion units to pike formations. Maybe the approach should be to have shot and pike as the two main infantry classes, and give a large bonus if they are used together in plausible ratios (or penalty it they are not). Artillery was mainly a seige thing in the earlier periods...it was just not that effective in most fiels battles. Artillery on its own should probably have a strength of 0 or very close against other troops.
The effect of fortifications was vital in this period..it was often the case that a moderate fortification with a garrison of a few hundred could tie down a major army for weeks, months, or in the cases of the best ones even years. This is just not reflected inthe game.
C16th and C17th warfare rarely used "light infantry" as such, wherere as in practice this is 90% of what is used in game: what was used was shot, which were effective mainly as companion units to pike formations. Maybe the approach should be to have shot and pike as the two main infantry classes, and give a large bonus if they are used together in plausible ratios (or penalty it they are not). Artillery was mainly a seige thing in the earlier periods...it was just not that effective in most fiels battles. Artillery on its own should probably have a strength of 0 or very close against other troops.
The effect of fortifications was vital in this period..it was often the case that a moderate fortification with a garrison of a few hundred could tie down a major army for weeks, months, or in the cases of the best ones even years. This is just not reflected inthe game.